Benton's Fig Bars are Aldi’s private-label fig-cookie bars positioned as an alternative to Nabisco Fig Newtons. Reviewers and forum users repeatedly describe them as softer and moister than the name-brand original, with a filling made from real figs. They target budget-conscious shoppers and anyone who prefers a denser, cake-like cookie with a fruit-forward filling.
This review synthesizes reporting and user feedback from a Mashed feature, Reddit threads, Facebook group posts, a longform blog review, and a YouTube taste-test referenced in the research brief. Where available I note package-level data cited by sources (a 14-ounce package and the nutrition observations recorded by a longform reviewer).
Overall verdict: Benton's Fig Bars deliver a pronounced fig flavor and a moister, softer crust than many recall from Nabisco Fig Newtons; users praise the amount and flavor of the filling. Downsides flagged repeatedly are the product's sugar density and portioning — one reviewer calculated roughly 1,400 calories per package and noted the bars are easy to overeat. If you prioritize texture and filling, these are a solid retail alternative; if you avoid high-calorie snacks or prefer a lighter cookie, they may be less suitable.
Fig-forward filling with noticeable sweetness
Multiple sources report the filling as distinctly figgy and flavorful; Mashed explicitly notes the filling's flavor, and a Facebook group post described the bars as “moist and delicious with plenty of filling.” User tasting commentary consistently favors the intensity of the fruit filling compared with the name-brand Fig Newton.
The longform blog review characterized the bars as “figgy and sweet,” so expect a noticeably sweet profile driven by the fig paste and sugars common to prepackaged fig bars.
Softer crust and denser, cake-like cookie body
Reporters and users repeatedly describe the cookie exterior as softer and moister than Nabisco Fig Newtons: Mashed calls out a softer mouthfeel and moister crust, while a Reddit commenter described the cakey part as “a little more dense.”
A 2017 blog review noted little crunchy fig seeds that “go ‘pop’ between the teeth,” so the texture combines a soft cookie, dense cake-like interior, and small seed crunch from real figs.
Made with real figs but concentrated in calories per package
Mashed reports the filling contains real figs, which aligns with multiple tasting notes about seed presence and fig flavor. The presence of real figs contributes to the texture and seed crunch described by reviewers.
A longform reviewer calculated roughly 1,400 calories for a full package and noted a serving-size reference of about 100 calories per two bars; that write-up also warns the bars are easy to overconsume due to pleasant sweetness and soft texture.
14-ounce package; portions can be easy to overeat
Mashed references a 14-ounce package as the typical pack size carried in many Aldi listings. A blog reviewer used package-level math to highlight the total calories and the tendency to eat multiple bars in a sitting.
Because several reviewers flagged easy overconsumption, portion control is a practical consideration: the combination of soft cookie and sweet, abundant filling makes single-serving restraint harder than with drier, thinner fig cookies.
How Benton's compares to name-brand Fig Newtons and homemade versions
Across Reddit, Facebook, and the Mashed feature, many tasters judged Benton's superior to Nabisco Fig Newtons on texture (softer/moister) and filling intensity. The Mashed article summarizes that sentiment and frames Benton's as a widely praised Aldi dupe.
By contrast, homemade Fig Newtons (discussed in a Facebook post referenced in the brief) are cited by some communities as tasting better than store-bought overall, but those are a different category (freshness and customization at the cost of convenience). A YouTube taste test in the brief also compared Benton's directly to the name-brand Newtons.
Pros & Cons
- ✅ Softer, moister cookie crust compared with reviewers' recollection of Nabisco Fig Newtons (Mashed; Reddit)
- ✅ Filling made with real figs — seeds and fig flavor are present (Mashed; Ain't Found review)
- ✅ Multiple user reports of “plenty of filling,” giving a fruit-forward mouthfeel (Facebook group post)
- ✅ Available in a 14-ounce package size commonly listed in coverage (Mashed)
- ✅ Described as denser/cakey in the cookie portion for those who prefer a more substantial bar (Reddit)
- ✅ Seed crunch from figs adds texture contrast noted by a longform reviewer
- ❌ Longform review estimated about 1,400 calories per package and noted roughly 100 calories per two-bar serving, highlighting concentrated calories
- ❌ Several reviewers warned the bars are easy to overeat because of sweetness and softness (Ain't Found blog)
- ❌ Some tasters describe the cookie interior as denser/cakey, which may not appeal to fans of thinner, drier Fig Newtons (Reddit)
- ❌ Described by a blog reviewer as noticeably sweet, which could be a downside for those avoiding high-sugar snacks
How It Compares to the Competition
- Nabisco Fig Newtons — The long-standing national brand; reviewers often find Benton's softer and moister while Nabisco maintains the thinner, drier bar profile some prefer.
- Homemade Fig Newtons — DIY versions emphasize freshness and customizable sweetness, and some home cooks claim superior taste, but they lack the convenience of prepackaged bars.
- Other store-brand fig bars (varies by retailer) — Private-label fig bars from other supermarkets vary widely; Benton's is repeatedly singled out in community threads for its softer texture and ample filling.
Who Should Buy This & Who Should Skip It
Buy it if: Buy Benton's Fig Bars if you prefer a softer, moister fig-cookie with a pronounced fig filling and seed texture, and if you value a ready-to-eat packaged alternative to Nabisco Fig Newtons. They're a good fit for shoppers who prioritize mouthfeel and a fruit-forward bar.
Skip it if: Skip these if you avoid high-sugar, calorie-dense snacks or need strict portion control—one reviewer calculated about 1,400 calories per package and warned they are easy to overeat. Also skip if you favor the thinner, drier Fig Newton texture.
Search Purchase Options
Use these links to search for Aldi fig-Newton-style alternative on trusted marketplaces. The links open in new tabs; if you buy through them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
* Affiliate links: you pay the same price either way.